Play whatever you want to play most! Personany I don't buy that people shouldn't play "overexposed" games but whatever. If you enjoy it and it is fun for you, that is what matters most.
I think The Walking Dead is the game of the year hands down. There have been no other games with characters as well written and well realized as The Walking Dead. And that last episode will go down in the history books among game endings. The only other game I truly loved this year was Borderlands 2, but it was flawed on a lot of levels.