Indie Horror games like 7 Days, Stairs, Pesadelo, Kraven Manor... and much more.
There is so much suspense, it's like a voyage with Poods until...POW! A jumpscare, and you jump out of your seat with him. (Oculus Rift ones aren't very pleasing to see and jumpscares aren't as good; you need to be with the oculus)
But Amnesia has to be the best longish-haul one (When he started playing Happy Wheels, lots of Bros and I were devastated that he had "left horror". I was pretty wrong, fortunately). Amazing gameplay, longer, a story that leaves you the whole day playing.
Wow.

And...Penumbra.
Of course.

i really like the time he played
- Eyes the horror game,
-amputea
his reactions were hilarious and funny!

That is so hard to pick just one lol, so many interesting games. Hmmm.....So far, I think its the South Park game he played.

I just looooved the 1d sim dating thing with mertzehia, i laughed tooo much! And the Sims also, that shit was hilarious and OH GOD Babysitter bloodbath was probably the funniest horror game ive watched. I really liked the walking dead if we are talking lets play, and south park seemed like a game that would be played alone and not on yt, but i love how pewds made it yt appropriate by cutting out the fighting scenes and battles. Why is he so perf?

My all-time favorite game PEWDS played is Skate 3 "Im the one who has a little fun, DO IT AGAIN!!!!!!"

I don't know if it was actually my favorite, but it definitely stands out - BULLY was one of my favorite playthroughs he ever did.

All of them.

My favourite games that Pewds played are Amnesia and Outlast :))))
Even Last of us it was really nice to see, but it wasn't full of funny parts caused by the shared fear :))