Okay, so I have three.
First of all, two games in particular out of the Silent Hill Series (though most of the series is good, these two in particular are pretty awesome)
Homecoming and Downpour. There's a little bit of a trade off with these two in my opinion, I think Homecoming is a bit more frightening, but the puzzles are also harder than the ones in Downpour (though I guess it depends what mode you play on). Both of the games are great horror games with great plots and they get right to the action from the beginning, with intros that you actually play through rather than watch. I enjoyed playing both of these and I highly recommend them to any lover of the horror genre.

I also would like to recommend Shadows Of The Damned, which is a Suda51 and Shinji Mikami (the Resident Evil creator). It is quite a scary game, but the scare factor is balanced with humor via the characters Garcia and Johnson and the puzzles are fairly easy in this game as well. The monster design is pretty amazing, and even just the looks of them sometimes is scary by itself. This game is very fast paced for the most part and is really fun to play.

I hope you consider the games, I think you would have a great time playing them and all the bros would enjoy watching X3 *brofist*