Didn't see this one on the list, so I decided to suggest it. Anyway, this is more for the bros than for pewdie, but he can still play it if he wants.

Basically, this is based on the (sadly on hiatus) web cartoon Homestar Runner, made by Mark and Mike Chapman. The game was published by Telltale Games, the creators of the Walking Dead game. Once again, I suck at descriptions, so here is a copypasted description from Wikipedia:

Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People uses point and click mechanics. The player plays as Strong Bad, one of the most popular characters in the Homestar Runner online flash animation series, as he goes through his life, interacting with characters. Each game contains a different goal that the player must reach by talking to characters and using items.Apart from the point and click mechanics, each episode features an arcade-style minigame. For example, the first episode features a top-down boxing game called Snake Boxer 5. Other features include a customizable map, hidden and collectible items such as 3×5 cards used to create Teen Girl Squal comics, and the ability to take pictures to send to friends through WiiConnect24 or by e-mail (depending on the version used).

It is available for Windows, Wii, Playstation 3 (with Move support), and Mac OS X. It is divided into episodes, like TellTale's other games.

Trailer (from the homestar runner site): homestarrunner.com/sbcg4ap.html
Another trailer from Telltale Games' youtube page: youtube.com/watch?v=ULy-1us8p1U

Screenshots:

And the website it's based on (note hasn't updated in 2 years): homestarrunner.com/

(sorry if I'm not following the template)