I think your game should be like a Mario Brothers game. Martzia is captured by Edgar and Maya and your goal is to try to save her by going through levels that are themed to you Like have a "fabulous" level , and have like a "duck" level or maybe even a "cry" level
Super Mario BROS is my idea.

I'm thinking about a kind of 2D adventure, like the one you played, but with elements from all the way back to your CoD and Minecraft videos throughout your YouTube career untill you end up back to this video. There will be highlights from your best moments, a counter in the left corner being the numbers of your subscribers at the time of those videos and only increases as you progress further

Other stuff could be added too to be a historical game about you

There should be Falcon Lover as a boss somewhere or an NPC

Pewds vs the world!! The enemies have to be chair monsters and variations of ducks and the point of the game rescue pugs that each give you different powers, high jump, air dash, double jump and temporary invincibility.

Or just tone down the platforming and make it like the old school megaman games, Shovel Knight would be an amazing game to get inspiration from.

Enemies: barrels, falcon lord( giraffes) , and random bloody limbs.
Characters: standard character: a bro(fan of pewds) upgraded character: edgar/maya. upgraded twice: Marzia. THE MAIN GOD TOP BEST character: fabulous pewds, tiara and the pink scarf etc. When u upgrade to pewds, you have special powers to protect the bros and special fabulizer rays that turn enemies into sugoi kawaii fab things.

Well i think a beat-em up game should be great, but a great bizarre, funny and fabulous adventure of yours could be even great.

This is what i was thinking:

-Beat-em up challenges or levels, puzzle levels, rage levels... and lots of jumpscares.
-A combo sistem, with you and Martzia, or you and Cry, you and Ken, etc... Obviously in times that they are some kind of asist CPU players.
-A rage mode called the "Fabulous Mode" for a certain lapse of time where you atack with superpowerful rainbows by carging the "Fab Bar" with "Fab Orbs" or something... (?)
-A kind of final atacks like "Rain of pugs"(You make pugs rain and damage all the enemies on the screen) or "Everybody is a Barrel" (you transform every enemy into weak barrels). All of these should be thiggered with your energy bar.
-Heavy or carged atacks like a "DEUTSCHLAND!" or a powerful "Rageful DEUTSCHLAND"
-Make Stephano your simbol of 1UP
-Something like a life bar, a "Energy Bar" that comes to be like a "Maná Bar"or something, and a EXP Bar
-Use a kind of stats like ATK, DEF, RES (Resistance), EBC (Energy Bar Capacity), FBD (Fab Bar Duration), CRT RAT (Critical Atack Ratio), and others that i don't remember that can be leveled up by level you up, or stat-upgrade items
-Make some kind of usable items like potions, energy potions, EXP potions, weapons, etc.
-And finally. In the end of the game, it can finish with a masive bro-fist with you and all the bros to defeat the final boss.

About the story line... well i don't know what will you and all the comunity wants, so i leave my ideas here to don't mess up anything.

A big bro-fist for everyone.

Characters: main= Pewds, Marzia, or Edgar (player's choice)

Pewds power- SUBSCRIBER SMACKDOWN= rains the power of the subs down on all enemies on the screen
Marzia's power- LOVE LASER= shoot a laser charged by the ultimate power of love at all your enemies, death by cuteness
Edgar's power- SUPER STINK= since Edgar always ruins pewds' recordings with his dog farts, his power is pretty self explanatory, and his stench gives Edgar a temporary shield

Enemies: Barrel, Amnesia Bro, and that ghost thing from pewduckpie.

Well at least have him kill ducks or Illuminati peeps with brofists and have a fabulous ray too

Character:
i think you should pick the character from someone you love or pick an character from the game you ever played but the first character can we play is you pewds
Abilities:
the abilities you should pick is from your faboulouses or your kawainess or you pick from the game you ever played and you think the power is badass,kawai, and faboulous
Enemies:
pick the enemies from someone you hates sooooo much or the enemies from the other games

And pewds i really hopes the games is RPG game with Xp , and items items from RPG games and thats my ideas
sorry for bad spelling because im not people who good in english
thankyohh

So the majority of the game will be a side scroller with other levels like a shooter scroller and puzzle games. Of course it has to be Kawaii af. next, make sure its nostalgic with many references. No rage quit game, the difficulty has to be enjoyable. make it a funny well written game.

Couldn't type on the forum earlier, but can't they make differend youtubers with each their own power which are their trademarks?

Like PewDiePie get a super strong brofist to punch the evil barrels.
Markiplier get some shuriken pink mustaches.
Cinnamentoastken should get bearclaws.
Cryotic could transform into an big white pounding beast.
Jacksepticeye gets to bowl with big eyes.
Lordminion777 gets to summon a purple bunny (I noticed he does Bonnie from Five nights at freddy's alot on like the Gmod and Animation and Drunk minecraft).
Muyskerm gets to blast them away with his trompet.
Tobuscus get to throw up at them or shoots with a gun off Darkness then Redness then Whiteness.
Cutepiemazia gets to summon Edgar and Maya which shoot with laser eyes.

Etc. cause there are alot off youtubers.

Well good luck on the game.

How about playin pewds and using fabulizer power to make the ennemies happy and just not kill them, you know, get friend with them?

I think barrels should be included as either an enemy, an obstacle, a hazard, or any combination of these.

You should have KAWAII BROFIST POWERS AGAINST THE EVIL DUCKS THAT HAVE BARRELS FOR ARMOR

Storyline
Pewds must save Marzia from the illuminati. And to do this pewds must use his trusty pugs and special 360 no scope training he will individually defeat celebrity's that have been suspected of being part of illuminati and when all are defeated he will have to face the the leader of illuminati plot insert plot twist here
Characters and special abbilities
Pewds:techno rage -after killing 69 enemies will gain a timed power that will make pewds shoot rainbow lasers out of his eyes and will make enemies dance due to the epic swag lord that is pewds
Edgar:farts of confusion-will make enemies become non hostile due to there confusion because of Edgar's god damn farting
Puga chan(Maya):puga's cute stare: will give pewds encouragement/health so that pewds will keep going and not give up

Hey pewds how ya doin? The idea i came up with is simple but could be epic if done right. So you're an average everyday mlg youtuber with a hatred for barrels .. little do you know that the barrels have been plotting from the beginning .. now they plan to dominate the world and turn everyone into barrels. Thats where you come in and realize you were the chosen one and you have to unlock the power of Dat Ass and harness the skills of a true 360 No Scope God and build the resistance better known as The Bro Army. Once you achieve these tasks you start your journey towards becoming the true chosen one and learning The Legendary Bro Fist and with it you will defeat King Barrel and save the world.

I think the game will be a Beat 'em up with other characters that you can play. Also PewDie's special is turning into a SUPER MONSTER DUCK!!!!
Helo from Latvia

PEWDS SHOULD HAVE A FART JUMP AND THE ENEMY SHUD BE JB (sry 2 any JB fans) AND THEN MARZIA SHUD BE LIKE A PLAYER 2 AND THEN EDGAR HAS FREAKING FART POWERS AND MAYA HAS A LASER POWER AND U GUYS HAVE TO DESTROY THE BEEVIL BEIBER (i meant to say "beevil") FROM TAKING OVER THE WORLD FROM LISTENING TO MASHUPS FROM HIS SONGS 4 ETERNITY

Boss idea- WALLY THE KILLER WHALE
Ability- Throws objects and water bombs at player.
Appearance- Killer Whale, wearing a top hat, and has an umbrella as a shield

ATTACK OF THE PUNK FISH!
Level idea-
Jumping into different game worlds through portals

Enjoy the ideas!!! please read!!

Toby Mac here. THis is my idea. Marzia has been stolen! The Enemy should be the Super Mega Hater SqTruad. They have leaders that consists of Edgar, Barrels, and then Falco Lover as the main leader. Each leader has their own domain that the player must defeat before fighting the ultimate boss, Super Mega Hater himself. Each domain will get harder, depending on the order of which the player has played. In each domain, the Leaders are the bosses and they have minions that are based off of them. Edgar's minions would be pugs and such. After defeating all leaders, the Player will have collected the 3 sided pendant(each side obtained after defeating a Leader), which is used to reach the Ultimate boss. And after defeating the SUper Mega Hater, you will receive and Eye part for the pendant thats been collected, to form the Illuminati Pendant. WHere Marzia is Truely found.