If you had to pick one: Outlast or Amesia: Machine for Pigs?

Outlast.

A Machine For Pigs is just the basic hiding from the enemy with puzzles thrown in. Outlast has an interesting story and a more interesting mechanic to me. And it had more jumpscares.

Karzahni wrote:

Outlast.

A Machine For Pigs is just the basic hiding from the enemy with puzzles thrown in. Outlast has an interesting story and a more interesting mechanic to me. And it had more jumpscares.

A Machine for Pigs... I did not even had to hide. I never really hid. I'd walk on the main path and then if I see something I'd stop at a corner. There is some running, but thats about it.

Outlast, is a lot more hiding and running. More jump scares. I suppose if you combine Outlast and Amnesia 2 together, you might have another awesome, great game.

Well, by the 'hiding from enemies' mechanic, I meant that all there is to getting past the enemies is hiding and running past. There's even zones they can't get to you, or just stop chasing after a certain point. I think that's pretty boring gameplay.