Whatever game this is , I'm so excited for the outcome!

Hm... but then, will he be making a video of him playing it? xD
I can't really imagine playing your own creation. It's like commenting on something you already know what's about to happen.

Personally, I don't think he himself will be creating the game. I moreso think he supervises the project and tell people what to do and see if he likes it and such.

I don't think it'll be open world, let alone as big as Skyrim or anything. Those games take hundreds of developers and millions of euros to make, I don't think Pewdiepie has either of those.
My guess is that it will be a 2D side scroller game (relatively cheap to develop) with lots of levels (eg. Angry Birds concept). Something along those lines.

Yeah, let's be real here. Pewdiepie would be too busy to himself be making the game. He'll be watching, telling the people making the game what he wants. But I suppose something along the lines of The Forest with lots of easter eggs would be hella sweet

I don't think is developing it, just kind of supervising it. But I would hope maybe some kind of horror, but in the end I would hope it would actually be something he would enjoy.

Could be anything, but I have a sneaky suspicion it is going to be a horror game
Not just an Amnesia mod/clone or any of the other horror games he plays, he's bored to death with how repetitive and unoriginal they are,
I believe he's got a cool idea for something that really sets itself apart and gives you proper scares.

EDIT: Just noticed the title "...would you like him to make"
Let him decide for himself > . < It's his game

Sadly enough, I think it will most likely be an Amnesia clone. xD

Probably a horror game :3 or like a rage game. It would be so hilarious to watch him rage on his own game xDD

It is going to be a game that he actually likes. He doesn't like horror games anymore and why would he make a rage game when it could be game that he actually wants to play?

It would be interesting if he did something a bit different and charming, with a unique art style. Sort of in the vein of Hansel & Gretel and Botanicula.

I think its going to be some really damn desu desu -over fabulous game.
And it's pink, of course!

Dancing games. Awesome. Swag.

I'm about to say this 2 options (what pewdiepie will develop):
1. FPS Game (MP)
2. Funny Multiplayer Game

My Child, this game will be blessed at birth.

pewds is awesome in playing video games, not developing them, of course he can hire someone to do it for him i guess.

I highly doubt that he is creating the game, probably just supervising the project.

If he could really do it .. I'd say a Horror Game !

Hey All!
I think we all would like to see an open world game featuring pewds. However, on a realistic scale, this will be very difficult. Of course he has the funds to support it, but unless he hires AAA quality P4H programmers, this project could take years and years, and the quality would not be very good. A horror/Simple Multiplayer(sort of like a PewDiePie TTT) would be more than possible. It also depends on what engine he builds it on. I myself use Unreal Engine 4, as the payment is only 20$ M.O and the Royalty is merely 5%. On top of this, the services and rendering on this Machine is built to stun. Of course, with Unity 5 set to release there may be alittle controversy, but I would still stand by my choice as I do not have 1600$ to spend on a license for Unity. Plus, UE4 requires you to have little to no programming language to build a game.
I myself am currently building a horror game on UE4. If you wish me to, I can make one on PewDiePie and have the alpha ready by mid Jan(hopefully). Of course, it would depend on the type of response I would get from you bros. Many may not be happy with a "PewDieBait" game, as you call it. Rest assured if you guys are keen on a horror game where you play as Pewds, I would be more than happy to make it. If any of you are yourself building a game and need help, feel free to send me a message
Cheers!
VB
99 BIT